The Power of Surprise: Why You Should Give More Mystery Gifts

March 10, 2025

Mystery Equals Excitement

In the world of casinos, the goal is to create an atmosphere of thrill, anticipation, and entertainment. So why are so many casino marketers giving away promotional gifts in a way that lacks the very excitement they strive to generate?

By keeping promotional gifts a secret until they’re revealed, casino marketers can build intrigue, enhance guest engagement, and boost the perceived value of their giveaways. Here’s why you should embrace the power of the unknown.

The Psychology Behind Mystery Gifting

Humans are wired to love surprises. The element of mystery triggers dopamine release, the same brain chemical responsible for the thrill of gambling. When guests don’t know the details of their reward, their anticipation builds, making the experience more engaging and memorable.

Studies show that uncertainty increases emotional investment. Casinos that leverage mystery gifting can create a buzz on the floor, keeping players engaged for longer and driving repeat visits. Whether it’s a high-end gadget or a branded keepsake, not knowing can intrigue guests.

Mystery Gifts & Traditional Giveaways - Finding The Right Mix

Traditional continuities are the tried-and-true giveaways. However, mixing a mystery giveaway into your promotional calendar will energize guests and increase redemptions.

Here’s how mystery gifts can invigorate your gifting strategy:

Boosts Perceived Value: A mystery item often feels more valuable increasing the perceived value for your guests.

Encourages Word-of-Mouth Buzz: Guests talk about mystery giveaways, sharing their curiosity and excitement with other players.

Promotes Additional Play: Guests stay longer or play more to earn their mystery reward.

Real-World Casino Mystery Uses

Many casinos across the country are currently implementing mysteries into their monthly gifting. Below are three examples:

M Resort Spa Casino offers monthly promotions where players earn tier points to claim a mystery gift, adding an element of surprise to standard loyalty rewards.

Seven Feathers Casino hosts a "Mystery Gift Giveaway" where guests earn points to receive an undisclosed gift.

Graton Resort & Casino runs a “Mystery Gift Card Giveaway,” where players receive a gift card of unknown value—keeping guests engaged right up to the reveal.

Make Mystery Gifting Work for Your Casino

If you are looking to incorporate mystery gifts into its promotions, here are a few best practices:

1. Keep the Mystery Authentic – Avoid revealing too many hints. A true mystery keeps players intrigued!

2. Use a Tiered Approach – Offer different mystery gifts based on play levels to encourage higher participation or tier advancement.

3. Create a Themed Experience – tie your mystery gift into the theme of a continuity, where the fourth item is a surprise that completes the set!

Ready to Add More Mystery to Your Gifting?

Mystery gifts aren’t just a way to use up unredeemed inventory - they can add a jolt of energy to your regularly scheduled gifting program! By incorporating mystery gifting into your casino’s promotions, you can stand out from competitors and offer players an experience they won’t forget.

Looking to integrate mystery gifts into your promotional strategy? Contact GPS today and discover how mystery gifting can work for your casino.

Back to Resources

The Power of Surprise: Why You Should Give More Mystery Gifts

March 10, 2025

In the world of casinos, the goal is to create an atmosphere of thrill, anticipation, and entertainment. So why are so many casino marketers giving away promotional gifts in a way that lacks the very excitement they strive to generate?

Want to see the full content? Enter your email and get full access.

To get full access to this resource, fill out the form and get the content straight to your inbox!